Is Your Investment Advisor Doing the Hokey Pokey?

Credit: stockimages at FreeDigitalPhotos.net

Over the last few months I have had numerous conversations with people regarding their investment advisor’s dance moves. It seems that over the past year there has been a lot of “dancing” going on in some people’s portfolios. Something along the lines of you put your money in the market, you pull your money out of the market, you put your money in the market and move your investment strategy all about. If that has been your investment advisor’s tune or you self-manage your investments and that’s your typical jam, I have one word for you: stop.

A strategy largely based on putting your money in and out of the market is essentially a market timing strategy, and imperfect timing is a very common cause of poor investment performance. The truth is, no one is smart enough or consistent enough to successfully invest with a money in and money out approach over a long period of time. Sure, you can be lucky and look brilliant over a short period of time, but, even so, the transaction fees and short term capital gains taxes generated by jumping in and out of the market time and time again will also diminish your investment returns.

Most people know they need to have a large portion of their assets invested to have a good shot at hitting their retirement goals and to protect their hard-earned assets against inflation. Investors need an overall investment strategy that is historically appropriate for their age and stage in life, withdrawal needs, and risk tolerance. Beyond that, it’s my professional opinion that relatively small tactical adjustments are appropriate when there are specific opportunities or risks in the market or world that you’re trying to navigate, but drastic investment strategy changes should be the exception - not the rule. Sometimes taking action and making a lot of changes in your portfolio can feel good, but “surgery by chainsaw” rarely works out best. Instead, considering things like the amount of U.S. versus international stocks, large cap versus small cap stocks, growth versus value stocks, corporate versus municipal bonds, and long-term versus short-term bonds can be a good idea. 

Consider this year for example. Who knew 2016 would get off to one of the worst starts for a calendar year in market history? What if you’d completely jumped out of the market in February because you thought it was the beginning of the next cyclical pullback and you missed the bounce back of March, April, and May and endured transaction fees and realized capital gains? How many people actually thought Great Britain would vote to leave the European Union? What if you’d completely jumped out of the market in June due to the surprise result, media barrage, and overreaction of other investors and you missed the swift recovery and positive market performance since then?

When investing you shouldn’t make too many one-way, all-in bets. You should view investing as a mechanism to give you a high probability of achieving your financial and life goals. Investing is a marathon, not a sprint. It’s not sexy and it’s not news, but I do firmly believe investing in a prudently diversified portfolio with a long-term outlook really does give you the best chance to accumulate and preserve wealth.

After all, isn’t that what it’s all about?

-Tom